Advice post-Montgomery

The Montgomery ruling requires that all reasonable options are discussed with patients to help them make a decision:

  • This does not mean that you are required to discuss all options available if they are not all appropriate/reasonable in a particular patient's case
  • You are not expected to be able to offer any and all treatments that can be found globally/in research settings
  • If a patient requests a treatment/procedure that you do not think is a reasonable or appropriate option, you can refer on to another clinician for a second opinion


Patients may still say 'You decide, I don't know what's best' and, as long as the different options have been considered and compared, you can guide the patient.

The 'therapeutic exception' should be not be abused

  • The circumstances where a patient will be harmed by being informed of the choices open to them and risks associated with the options, will not be rare

Patients are allowed to choose no treatment or to pick an option that may not be the best option in your professional opinion

A patient can say ‘I don’t want to know the risks’

  • Discuss and try to find out if there is anything underlying this position
  • If the patient genuinely does not wish to know and they understand that they may not be able to make a balanced decision as a result, they do not have to be told
  • It is important to document all discussions carefully

Medical Consent The Montgomery Case


See also

documentation advice

Best practice in documentation

View

Health Literacy and Communication Techniques

Health Literacy and Communication Techniques

View

Tips for foundation doctors, trainees and their supervisors

Tips for health care professionals

View

Shared decision making

Shared decision making

View

Login
Log in using your username or email address. You can also use your College Personal ID (PID) if you have one.

Forgotten password?


Create a login

New users must create a login. You do not need to be a member of the College in order to create a login.

Register

Help

Having difficulty registering or logging in? Forgotten your username or password?

Get Help